Fremantle Dockers ratings: Danielle Laidley ranks every player based on pre-season win over Melbourne Demons

Fremantle Dockers Ratings: Danielle Laidley Ranks Every Player Based on Pre-Season Win Over Melbourne Demons

In a thrilling pre-season match that saw Fremantle triumph over the Melbourne Demons, there was no shortage of standout performances, as well as moments that showed areas for improvement. Former AFL player and coach Danielle Laidley provided her expert analysis and ratings of each player’s performance. With the Dockers hoping to bounce back in 2025 after a mixed 2024 season, this victory over the Demons was a significant step forward. Here’s a breakdown of how Laidley ranked Fremantle’s players after the highly anticipated clash.

1. Andrew Brayshaw – 9/10 Brayshaw’s leadership and composure were on full display, and he was easily one of the best on ground. His ability to win the ball in the middle of the ground and set up forward opportunities was key to Fremantle’s victory. Laidley lauded his “mature, composed” performance and noted that Brayshaw’s influence as a captain is undeniable.

2. Caleb Serong – 8.5/10 Serong continues to grow as one of Fremantle’s most consistent and dynamic midfielders. His attack on the ball and relentless work rate around the ground made him a standout. Danielle highlighted his ability to win clearances and transition the ball quickly. She was particularly impressed by his “toughness at the contest” and felt he was a key contributor to Fremantle’s dominance in the middle.

3. Luke Jackson – 8/10 The former Melbourne Demon turned Docker was instrumental in Fremantle’s forward structure, especially in the ruck. His height and mobility gave Melbourne’s defenders headaches, and his ability to both contest in the air and contribute to the ground game were praised. Laidley noted that his presence in the forward 50 was a “game-changer” and a glimpse of what the Dockers hoped for when they secured him.

4. Nat Fyfe – 7.5/10 Fyfe, who has been transitioning into more of a forward role, showed plenty of promise in the pre-season clash. His contested marking and ability to read the play stood out, and his experience was invaluable. Laidley was impressed by how Fyfe continues to adapt his game and felt his presence in the forward line could become even more potent as the season progresses.

5. Michael Walters – 7/10 Walters, the crafty small forward, was dangerous throughout the match, providing both creativity and skill inside 50. His footwork and ability to find space were key in setting up scoring opportunities for Fremantle. Laidley noted that while Walters was “not at his absolute best,” his class was still evident, and his influence on the scoreboard was enough to earn him a solid rating.

6. David Mundy – 7/10 The veteran midfielder, who is entering the twilight of his career, showed he still has plenty to offer. While he didn’t have as much impact as in his prime, Laidley acknowledged Mundy’s leadership in the midfield and his smart decision-making. She described his performance as “reliable,” noting that he still plays a crucial role in stabilizing the Dockers when the game gets tight.

7. Rory Lobb – 6.5/10 Lobb had moments where his height and mobility were effective, particularly in the air. However, his output in terms of marking and goal-kicking left something to be desired. Laidley pointed out that Lobb’s inconsistencies in the forward 50 might be a concern going forward but added that with more time in the system, he could find more rhythm and build on his pre-season performance.

8. Hayden Young – 7/10 Young showed his class as a rebounding defender, playing an important role in setting up the Dockers’ attacks from half-back. His decision-making was generally solid, but Laidley felt there were a few moments where his decision-making under pressure could improve. Nonetheless, she highlighted his composure and his important role in Fremantle’s defensive setup.

9. Liam Henry – 6.5/10 Henry’s electric pace and flair were evident throughout the game, but his decision-making in tight situations and execution let him down at times. Laidley emphasized that while Henry’s speed and creativity are undeniable, he needs to become more consistent and disciplined with his ball use in critical moments.

10. Blake Acres – 6/10 While Acres didn’t set the world on fire, Laidley praised his defensive work and his ability to provide a contest. She felt his energy was vital in a game that fluctuated in momentum. However, she added that his offensive output needed improvement, with some missed opportunities in attack, and noted that he’ll need to step up in the season ahead.

Key Takeaways:

Danielle Laidley was impressed by Fremantle’s collective efforts, especially in midfield and forward line. The Dockers appeared sharper in the contest, with Brayshaw and Serong setting the standard for intensity. The addition of Luke Jackson added a different dimension to the forward line, and while Fremantle showed glimpses of brilliance, Laidley felt there were areas to work on, especially in terms of consistency and converting opportunities.

Laidley concluded that Fremantle had the right mix of youth and experience, but they needed to continue building momentum to make a serious impact in the 2025 AFL season. The Dockers would be pleased with their pre-season performance, but they will know that the real test begins when the regular season starts.

This pre-season win over the Melbourne Demons was a step in the right direction for Fremantle, and with the leadership of Brayshaw, the emerging talents of Serong, and the experience of players like Fyfe and Mundy, the Dockers look poised to make a strong push in 2025.